Vending
Machine manufacturers- please make future products
more trouble free and easy for anyone to operate and maintain*!
This page is so that those
contemplating getting Vending machines can learn from our
experiences. We have an AMS refrigerated snack machine and a Dixie
Narco 600 drink vending machine. They are a whole bunch better than the
eternally malfunctioning drink machine the guy from the local drink
place brought by, from which we made barely enough to cover the
electric cost. For the most part, we are mostly getting what we
wanted- machines that at least mostly work most of the time. It's
been about a year, and most of this time only 70% - 90% of the
selections have been operating. Considering
the enormous price- over $3,000 each, we expected these brand new
machines to be a little more trouble free. Old vending machines seem to have a reputation
for being troublesome, but I think the bigger problem is that there
is no one in the vending machine repair business and the machines
don't come with much in the way of owners manuals or easy to use
parts lists. So we figured we would buy two new vending
machines and not have these problems.
Please email me if you have had any experiences with
these machines or any other Washington, DC or Virginia vending
machine companies! We would have bought a Coffee / Hot Coco vending
machine machine by now, but considering the troubles with the
machines we have, we decided it would be more troubles instead of
more convenience.
Vending machines can be a scam by companies that offer to finance
machines aimed at those who think there is
nothing involved in maintaining the machines. Apparently there are
companies that sell and finance vending machines in an unscrupulous
manner, promising an easy money making business selling cheap off brand machines that the owner
can not find out who manufactured, or where to go for service (State Sales
is NOT one of these companies).
It is not an easy
money business, and those thinking they will buy a bunch of machines
and retire will be in for a little reality check. They
constantly need attention, especially our AMS Snack machine. My pre
purchase investigations mostly consisted of asking around to see what other
folks who owned machines used and where they got them, and the Dixie
Narco was recommended as being a good drink vending machine. I asked the advice of
the guys at State Sales what they would get if they were buying a
refrigerated snack machine, and the AMS brand came up.
Keep in mind we are running a skydiving business. We don't have
time to devote a lot of attention to learning all there is to know
about vending machines. However,
although all conversations with State Sales were about machines with $5 /$1 bill changers,
we somehow ended up with a $1
bill only (in addition to coins, of course). The Mars brand
bill/coin changers are so far trouble free, although we had a coin
mech problem that State
Sales took care of on warrantee for us in December 2001. Both machines have
identical coin/bill changers, and use the same key, which is helps
make life simple.
In spite of the following
saga of troubles, these things seem to be paying for themselves
(2-3
years till they pay for themselves, if not a bunch sooner, then we start making money) and
providing the convenience we were after, and they still beat selling
things over the counter one at a time by hand. So we are still
arguably getting our money's worth, except for having made
the mistake of getting the mostly non-functional gum/mint
tray on the snack machine.
As
long as this web page has been up, I just got my first response
today from someone else selling and servicing Vending machines in
Virginia! They are:
Mike
Whalen
cme@ecinet2000.com
CME Inc
Culpeper, VA
(540) 937-7523 Culpeper, VA number
(800)
365-1417
Cell (757) 287-3716
Were I to buy another vending machine, I would certainly give
these folks a call. They are dealers for U-Select-It
(U-S-I) International I have not had any dealings with them,
though.
Another
response from someone who serviced vending machines in Virginia:
I have
been in the vending industry, first as a vendor and then as
the Service Manager for a distributor serving the Va/Md/DC area.
I read your site with interest. In my experience situations
like yours are not uncommon. Frequently distributors
(like Betson) focus almost
exclusively on sales and neglect service. Apparently they
are unaware that poor service results in people calling someone
else the next time they want to buy something. I
recently left the company I was working for, in part because
of that very attitude, and the fact that I was the Service
Manager, yet service was not an important part of the company's
overall plan.
Here's a response I got from another fellow who has found
another reliable vending machine:
Thanks for taking the time to write your experience about your
vending business. Sorry it has been a hassle. we have a Automatic
Product snack machine (AP LCM2). We have it for 4 years now
and we never had a single problem with it. It is not a
refrigerated machine. We are looking to buy a pop machine and
had been recommended a Dixie Narco. We are not looking to do
bottles, only can soda. After reading your experience with
Dixie I'm going to research more. Do you have any comments on
all-can Dixie machines? Thanks.
Ned responds:
I would get another Dixie Narco, especially if just set up
for regular cans. the problem was the distributor, not the machine,
not the manufacturer.
To the editor,
I have operated a vending business in Savannah, Ga for
twenty-five years. I am authorized to repair any make and model of
vending machine ever made. Your problem was not with the
manufacturer it was with the distributor. AMS and Dixie Narco are
both great machines. Are they 100% reliable all the time? NO
AMS has done a lot with their snack machines since you had your
problems. I have five of their machines on location as a test and we
only had one problem in a year and our distributor drove 200 miles
to fix it the next day. I prefer Dixie to any other Can/Bottle
vendor including Royal. That being said I have over twelve hundred
snack machines on location and 95% of them are made by Automatic
Products. These machines along with Crane National snack machines
are the Cadillacs of the vending business. Just remember the machine
is only going to be as good as the tech that prepped it and the
distributor that sold it. I get a hundred dollars an hour for
service calls and half the time it is flipping a switch that the
customer should have been knowledgeable enough to do. Oh well I have
rambled on enough.
Thanks,
Robin S. Rawls
-July 2003
DRINK
VENDING MACHINE-
DIXIE NARCO-
After over a year, Only 7 out of 9 selections work on the
Dixie Narco Drink Machine. All selections have never worked
at the same time except for a few weeks when it was new.
This machine is for cans and bottles,
the problem is that bottles come in different sizes and shapes, and
water bottles tend to collapse when they get cold. So after
trying to sell 16.9 oz bottled water, we learned that 20 oz
bottles work better, but it is rather hard to find 20 oz
bottled water. There is no comprehensive written guide included
with the vending machine advising how to shim all types of bottles.
The clips that hold the display items
are very strong, and several times when we removed the display can
it popped open, making a mess of the display area. They need to
improve the clips so they don't squeeze as much, and so they are not
as sharp. This will probably be a source of many more messes over
the years.
The intention was to sell everything in bottles, so people would
put the caps back on, and things would not get spilled too bad, but in fact cans are the only thing that the
machine works consistently well with since they are all the same
size and shape.
07/17/01
Mark,
the State Sales rep has still not come by to fix the remaining problems, despite having
said he would on two separate occasions. The snack machine works
well as long as we unplug it occasionally, except that the Gum/Mint
tray is now totally non functional.
7 of 9 selections still work on the
Drink Machine. In the year that we have owned it, there was
about one month that all the selections worked at the same time.
04/14/01-
Mark
came by two weeks ago and rearranged things in the drink
machine so now we are using 20 oz water bottles, which seem
to work great. We still have a lot of 16.9 oz bottles (not a
recommended size since they deform too easy) , which he
managed to get working OK as long as we don't fill the
column more than half way up so the bottles don't smash. We
will bring some parts to replace what has been messing up
the column that originally had water in it, but we have
since had the double column mess up again, probably because
we let the cans on the bottom row get pushed too far to the
back below the baffle, so now 7 of 9 columns are operable.
He didn't charge us anything for the service call, and
expect him to come by again soon to resolve the remaining
problems.
03/ 16/01-
No reply
whatsoever from emailing Mark, so I FAX the same message to State
Sales. Wayne calls me up and says he will arrange for Mark to come
by and replace the circuit board and replace the broken snack
machine part on warranty. Suggesting the water would dispense better
in single column instead of the double column slot, and in 20 oz instead of the flimsier 16.9 oz bottles, we plan to have
mark work his magic in switching which columns we use, and buy a
bunch of 20 oz water.
SNACK
VENDING MACHINE-
AMS-
The AMS Gum/Mint Tray is totally non-functional,
and has never worked properly.
We got a refrigerated snack machine so that we would not have
melted candy bars in the summer. It has condensation problems pretty
bad, though. The snack machine has had a lot of little problems.
There are a couple items we can not get to work- press the buttons
and nothing happens, like it does not register electronically or
something. (We fixed this keypad problem thanks to help from AMS
tech service December 2001)
One of the little plastic bracket that holds one of the
helical coils broke. The steel helical coils that rotate and deliver
the goods are plated steel, and getting rather rusty, again probably
from the condensation seems to me a Teflon coating would be the
thing.
Also the threaded pin that screws in to
hold the door shut has never lined up properly. You have to
wrestle with the door in order to raise it and get the pin to align
in order to close it every time you refill or open the machine for
any reason.
Our AMS
snack vending machine has operated at about 70- 80% of capacity
depending on the mood of the machines (really, the AMS Snack vending
machine seems to have some sort of circuit malfunction in cold
weather where at least one row & column is inoperable until it
is warmed up or is unplugged
and replugged in) (We fixed this
keypad problem thanks to help from AMS tech service December 2001)
The Gum /Mint tray
option has never been more than half operational at best. It is made by
AMS, and seems not to have enough spring force to push the remaining
items foreword to be dispensed. The spring/ cover arrangement is such
that it takes great care when refilling and closing the gum / mint
trays, otherwise the contents spurt up out of place in a disorderly
manner and require replacing one at a time. It looks like this is a
poorly designed option, and I don't recommend it.
There is also a bundle of wires hanging
down inside so it gets caught in the door every time you close it.
03/07/01-
I
contact State Sales for help with both machines- see 03/07/01-
above
02/19/01-
Once it
got warmer, the AMS Snack Vending Machine started to work normally-
even the right row of snacks works normally, so when it got cold and
failed again, we aimed a propane heater toward the keypad to test
the theory. Seems like a row of the keypad messes up when it gets
and stays too cold. (We fixed this
keypad problem thanks to help from AMS tech service December 2001)
--------------------------
--------------------------
01/21/01-
Our AMS Vending machine has ceased to
dispense anything.
--------------------------
--------------------------
11/1/00:
We have
still not resolved any of the problems with our vending machines,
and are using only about 4/5 of the potential capacity of the AMS
vending machine. The whole right row of the slots for snacks is non
functional.
--------------------------
--------------------------
9/25/00:
The saga
starts with our purchase of both machines April, 2000.
A big problem with these machines is the lack of a handy
print manual. The programming instructions are inside the machine on both
of them, on decals awkwardly arranged so that you need to push the
appropriate buttons outside the machine, and if you need to take
another peek at the instructions, stop and look inside the machine
(in the case of the drink vending machine, this requires finding
your place again on an enormous small print instruction decal) and
then returning to the outside of the door to again continue. There
is not as much as a parts list with it's invaluable diagrams to be found for either.
A good print manual would make it easy to sit down with and look over
instead of fiddling with the machine a little at a time when something
needs to be done.
* I
would like to see an easy to use owner's manual with complete
instructions, exhaustive search index for problems, and troubleshooting.
VENDING
MACHINE MANUFACTURERS, DISTRIBUTORS:
If
Automobiles worked like this, requiring constant repairs just to keep them
operating as expected and only 80% operational, consumers would be very unhappy and irate. It looks to me like the
industry severely needs COMPETITION among vending machine DISTRIBUTORS, manufacturers, and
especially vending machine sales and service providers to
make better products and provide better service. This looks like an opportunity for
Japanese, Taiwan and South Korean vending machine manufacturers and
engineers to do for the industry what they did for the automotive
industry, make reasonably priced products that are more reliable than ever
and last longer.
|